|
Tuesday, July 12. 2011
Oct. 9, 2009Amazed by the results - Schmalzried
I am a 44 year old who (much like a Golden Retriever) was
apparently born with dysplasia in my right hip. Never really bothered me
growing up though I would have a little pain when I walked a long way and
never knew why. Around age 33 my hip started to ache more often and for more
prolonged periods. By the last couple of years I would go a week or two with
slight pain then one to four weeks of significant pain that made it hard to
sleep and impossible to play with my kids or exercise. Of course, I had been
diagnosed 8 or 10 years ago but wanted to wait on surgery as long as
possible. This summer was as long as possible! This site was fantastic as a
research tool and I was pleased to find that a real expert in resurfacing
was so close by. I visited Dr. Schmalzried for a consult and was extremely
impressed by him and his staff. Everyone there was friendly and seemed to
know exactly what they were doing. To cut this a little short I had my right
hip done by Dr. Schmalzried on 8/31. They used a combination of an epidural
and light general which made waking up a bit easier. I was wheeled into my
room around 12:30 PM and, with the epidural still effecting things, felt no
pain. Around 4:00 the therapist came in and had me walk down the hall with a
walker. I had limited ability to control my legs but felt pretty good
otherwise. The next couple of days in the hospital were pretty easy. I had
intravenous pain medication and never really had any discomfort. I was
taught to give myself Lovenox shots which was not something I looked forward
to but turned out to be pretty easy. PT continued twice a day and was tough
but again, no real pain. The worst part was getting the catheter and the
drain removed!
Continue reading "John's Hip Resurfacing with Dr. Schmalzried 2009"
Tuesday, July 12. 2011
Surgery scheduled august 18 2009 Dr Poole Boise, ID
Still a few weeks to go, but I thought I would get myself
set up here. Been spending way too many late nites exploring this site- it
is great. I am feeling apprehensive about the surgery- resurfacing on the
left hip. I am 44 years old and female. Some days I think I can handle this
pain and then I take a step and actually cry out loud with pain and feel
very glad August 18 is right around the corner. It's been a long road since
December when things with my hip really went wrong. I have had years of
issues with it. I was a serious student of ballet for many years and have
been practicing yoga for nearly 30 years. I honestly never thought it would
come to this... but what can you do. The right hip has issues as well, not
quite as severe, and there is some hope that once the left hip is resurfaced
the right hip will settle down a bit. OK- I will post again when it is
closer to surgery! Lyn
5 days til surgery
Big day yesterday as had pre surgery tests (no big deal)
hip class (more reassuring than helpful as I have done such extensive
research, but getting to talk to the PT and OT I will be working with was
really great) and a meeting with my surgeon- our first since our initial
meeting nearly 5 months ago- when I had 20 minutes of his time- was told I
was a candidate for resurfacing and was not prepared at all with the
millions of questions that would form over the next months while I waited
for my surgery date (yes, it took 5 months to get one- I am a New Yorker
living in Idaho- only two surgeons doing the procedure in Boise and
evidently a long waiting list). I am 44, female, have a long history of
serious ballet study, yoga for 30 years, figure skating, and admit I was a
bit reckless with my body with respect to eating disorders and care in my
earlier adult years...all of which results in being here today. My arthritis
as it shows up on the xrays is only moderate- far more advanced than it
should be for my age- but not severe- yet. I have floating chondral and non
chondral bodies- one that is quite large and is lodged in a place where it
is likely causing some extra special pain~ My MR Arthrogram did not indicate
a labral tear, not that this means anything as they often don't show up, but
my surgeon somewhat surprised me yesterday with his reply when I asked, with
some doubt as we looked at a new xray, "Is my arthritis really so bad that
it requires this resurfacing- and if not- why do I have all this friggin
pain?" He said, "I strongly suspect you have a labral tear in addition to
bone spurs in addition to cysts in addition to the arthritis that is
evident." "Labral tear" sent me lurching into a mental backslide. I have
done the research, I know the odds of the scope surgery- esp when there is
significant arthritis present- which it is in my case, I don't want to give
away another year of my life to pain only to end up back on the waiting list
for a resurfacing...but I also don't want to lose a hunk of my hip joint if
I don't have to... So big restless nite followed by several hours on the
forum here on surfacehippy and I am almost 100 percent back on track with
confidence about my decision to do the resurfacing. I don't think I am a
viable candidate for trying scope surgery first, my surgeon says I am not
and neither he nor the sports medicine guy I started out with have any
confidence in the scope surgery and its success rates. I want my life back.
I want to be able to walk more than a block w/o debilitating pain, I want to
do yoga again, skate, hike, ---- have sex- everything that has been taken
away from me this past year. I have felt this coming for some time- even if
i did not have a name for it. Started about 5 years ago with acupuncture and
cranial sacral and massage and whatever i could find to try and "heal" the
hips. Yes, I did have an event- a very intense hip opening yoga session in
response to increased hip pain back in December 2008- December 23 to be
exact- felt ok- went to bed- woke up with pain off the scale and completely
unable to walk for a week- on crutches for another 2 weeks after that- and
slowly the pain has become manageable--- perhaps tore the labrum that nite-
perhaps it is when some of the cartilage lodged between the bones found its
new home- who knows... but I have been having recognizable hip issues since
my early 20's. So, my job now is to stop second guessing myself. I have done
hundreds of hours of reading and research- reaching out to those who have
had the surgery- read all the negatives on trying the scope to "repair" the
labrum... and I have made my decision... but I am going to keep coming back
to surface hippy every day until my surgery on the 18th to keep my mental
state strong.
Continue reading "Lyn's Hip Resurfacing with Dr. Poole 2009"
Tuesday, July 12. 2011
Steve's hipI just had surgery at Wake Forest Medical
Center with Dr. Jinnah. Here is my story. Since I live in Virginia there
were a few logistics about how I would get to and from the hospital. I have
many friends who are pilots and one volunteered to take me to Wake Forrest
and also provide the return trip. I was not worried about getting down there
but getting back would pose some challenges. I went down with a companion
and we stayed at the Hawthorne the night before. Not a bad place and they do
have a shuttle.
If I had to do it again though I would check out the Wingate. The morning
of surgery we went over at 6:30 AM and waited for 2 hours. I was called into
prep and that lasted about 30 minutes. My companion was allowed to wait
until it was time to take me in. When I was ready they gave me a "cocktail"
to make me sleepy. The next thing I remember was waking up in Post op. I had
a spinal block. There was no ill affects and it was much better than full
anesthesia. I felt nothing.
The first day I was pretty groggy but my pain was managed well. I never
got above 3 on a 1-10 scale. Slept fine the first night. They took the
catetheter out ( it was put in when I was asleep in surg) and I was hoping I
would be able to urinate. That turned out not to be the case and by 6 that
night I was uncomfortable. They had to reinsert the catheter but because of
my swelling it was difficult and took 4 attempts. That was very
uncomfortable. When they were about to go for number 5 (the fourth one
failed) I said "enough" and was somehow able to make it happen. From there
on ..no problems. My recommendations here is to see if you can take Flowmax
before surgery. They put me on it after that point and I have had no
problems.
In the hospital you get training from PT and OT which is not much as you
don't need much. Its all about learning how to do certain things without
breaking hip restrictions. It was easy and fun. I was walking the day after
surgery, not fast but fine. Wake forrest likes to use walkers that work very
well.
I was discharged on Wednesday and made the flight home. I basically had
to back into the back section of our small plane ( a bonanza). It was very
similar to getting in or out of a car. As advised I have been staying ahead
on my pain meds which has helped.
Thursday ( first day home) I slept fine last night, no issues. In the
morning I got up and was able to go the bathroom and had my first bowel
movement since surgery. No big deal. I have been taking Fibercon which seems
to work fine. There has been much talk about drugs causing constipation and
it is a concern but not a huge one. First , take the pain pills, whatever
you're concerns are about constipation they are minor compared to effect of
pain on your recovery. If you hurt you don't move as much, drink as much and
so everything is slower. From my experience I would say drink as much as you
can and take a stool softener (they will prescribe one probably) Then
something like Fiberone.
I am in less pain today and was able to go down the stairs (12 of them)
without any issues. The swelling in my leg is starting to go down so walking
is easier. It is easy to overdue so I would suggest taking many small walks
and resting as well for the first couple weeks. At this point I would say
that the surgery and recovery is much less problematic than I imagined.
Tuesday, July 12. 2011
One week post opI'm a 42 year old who had a left HR with Dr Gross on
June 3, 2009. I am fairly heavyset (x Offensive lineman) and when I met with
Dr Gross the day before, he responded that "I might be difficult.".
After the surgery, he told my wife that I was the hardest one he's done
this year, and instead of the operation taking an hour it took nearly 2hrs
and 15 min.
I have a very good friend who had her hip resurfaced four weeks ago with
Dr Mont and we are both very happy with the outcomes so far.
Here are some things that I've found to be strongly in favor of Dr Gross.
(1) Minimally invasive normally with steristrips. Although it doesn't seem
like much, was able to shower the day after the operation. no staples to
remove 2) I'm not a doctor, but the blood spinning procedure, where they
spin out the platelets and put about 300 cc back into the wound for quicker
recovery 3) DEXA scan determines how long you stay on crutches. In my case with
good bone density, doc said crutches one week and cane for a week, then
nothing. I'm not quite ready for the cane, but happy to know that I can
graduate when ready!
4) Icing the wound is so critical after the surgery,
and they gave me this little cooler with a clever pump and blanket that
keeps my wound cool for several hours. The device is called a polar care
300. It is definitely the neatest gadget I've seen in years. Could use it
for any other injury recovery. 5) Administration. Everything is wired and
designed to get you home if you are ready to go home. There is a nice hotel
right across the parking lot from the hospital. I had my surgery on Wed
morning and left the hospital at noon on Friday.
Tuesday, July 12. 2011
Dr. Su and the Hospital for Special Surgery
I had a right hip resurfacing on 3/5/09 performed by Dr. Edwin Su at the
Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS). It is now 3/23 - I am feeling great and
walking comfortably with the use of a cane. The lead up to surgery was two
years of limping and pain. The decision to have surgery was an easy one.
After doing my research - much of which was on this site - I met with Dr. Su
once, on 1/29/09. He recommended resurfacing (I'm 55) -- I agreed. Christina
(his assistant) took it from there -- her demeanor leading up to the surgery
was both professional and reassuring.
3/5/09 arrived quickly. Everyone associated with the HSS
is to be commended. The intake was seamless. Zoey (sp? - the intake nurse)
and John (who prepped my hip) were both engaging and thorough (in fact John
made it a point to visit me twice while I was in the hospital). Dr. Su
visited me before the operation, and as he did when I first met him, he put
me totally at ease with his quiet confidence, compassion, professionalism
and his obvious love for what he is doing. Soon thereafter I was wheeled
into the OR - followed by an epidural and sedation.
I woke up in the recovery room approximately 2 hours
later. No pain, just muscle soreness and stiffness in my right hip. I had
great care in the recovery room (I was there overnight as beds were in short
supply on this particular Thursday night - my surgery was at 6:30 PM.) The
activity in the recovery room acutually served to pass the time and the
warmth and caring of Eileen (the recovery nurse) and the others who attended
to me there was much appreciated. I had my first visit from PT -- Mia and
Lee. They were engaging and understanding and had me up and about in a
walker.
By Friday afternoon I was in a room - East River view no
less! Mia and Lee visited me in the afternoon and in the evening Suzanna
(from PT) took me for yet another "stroll" with a walker. Her good humor was
wonderful. Dr. Su came by in the evening after what I can only imagine was a
very long day, sat on the window sill and chatted. He fielded all my myriad
questions with his usual grace.
Saturday began with Rebecca from PT and a choice of
crutches -I chose the metal forearm version. Walking with crutches was not a
problem - although lightheadedness sent me back to my room before I could
try the stairs (a prerequisite for discharge).
Later that morning Dr. Su called (from his home) to check
on my progress! My room nurse was Jordan - friendly, humorous, informative
and patient - as capable a professional as I have ever been around. At
around 3 PM Rebecca from PT returned - this time I passed the stair test.
Rebecca was encouraging, patient and caring.
I was discharged thereafter and had dinner at my kitchen
table with my family at 6:30 PM pm on 3/7 -exactly 48 hours after my
surgery. As noted above it is now 3/23 - my recovery has been slow and
steady with the muscle soreness and stiffness getting better every day.
Daily walks and visits from Farel (home PT) have gotten me stronger and
steadier on my feet. My next visit to Dr. Su is on 4/1.
Tuesday, July 12. 2011
July 28. 2008
Hi, firstly congratulations and many thanks for the
excellent website and fantastic information. It was really helpful.
I am now 3 months on from a resurfacing to my left hip using an ASR device.
The orthopedic surgeon was Dr Sittiporn from Bumrungrad Hospital in Bangkok
Thailand. He tells me I am hip resurfacing patient number 44 for him. I
understand he trained at the Birmingham Clinic and I cannot recommend him highly
enough.
I am 51 and have always been active completing endurance adventure races but
now mainly into cycling both road and mountain biking. I have had hip pain for
about 10 years and earlier this year the pain became worse, my movement was
restricted and I developed a noticeable limp. I was putting most of my weight on
my right leg and there was a lack of power in the joint. There is a history of
hip problems in my family with my mother and 3 of her brothers having hip
replacements.
Dr Sittiporn advised a hip resurfacing procedure. I asked him that I wanted
to be pain free, improve my mobility and continue with my exercise program which
is 3 rides (150 km) and 3 swims (6 km) per week.
The operation went very well and the care at Bumrungrad was excellent. I was
in hospital for a week and then on crutches and physio.
Initially I tried to do far too much and pushed the rehab to far too fast
despite the good Doctor's advice. This resulted in pain, frustration and lack of
progress. I found by listening to my body and taking the Dr's advice I
progressed really well. I kept up the crutches for a week or two longer to get
better support and did all the rehab exercises.
Now at 3 months I can walk in the hills for 3-4 hours, am pain free and no
more limp. I have gained more flexibility and power and am back riding with the
peleton in Bangkok albeit around 30-50 kms at a time without any problem. I am
conscious of not falling off as that could pose a problem. Swimming has
progressed really well and I can now do without the float between the legs. It
has been a very positive experience for me and would certainly recommend the
procedure, the doctor and the hospital.
Best of luck Ray
Tuesday, July 12. 2011
After three years of groin pain, I began researching options
to improve my quality of life. In 2005, I met with two different Orthopedic
surgeons both of whom recommended surgery as the only option. While visiting a
friend @ Community General Hospital, I saw an information board regarding
"Birmingham Hip Resurfacing". I talked about the technique with my Orthopedist
and his recommendation was a Total Hip Replacement. Dr. Michael Clarke, who is
in the same practice, was an Orthopedist specializing in BHR and I immediately
made an appointment with him. Following the initial meeting, I began a quest to
learn as much about the BHR technique as possible. Your website "Surface
Hippies" was of great value. I scheduled my surgery for a LBHR with Dr. Clarke
on March 19, 2008.
I was Dr. Clarke's first surgical patient of the day. I went into the OR @
7:30am and was in recovery by 9:00am. I woke up around 11:00am and was
transferred to my room. In addition to the patient administered catheter, Dr.
Clarke uses a post-operative "painbuster" catheter that infuses medications
directly into the wound. (Day 1): walking with the aid of a walker. (Day
2):physical therapy and step climbing, up two steps, cross a platform and down
two steps then walked back to my room. (Day 3) physical therapy in the morning
and headed for home around noon. (Days 4 thru 7):switched from narcotics for
pain to extra strength Tylenol as the narcotics tend to have a paradoxical
effect. Lots of swelling initially but diminished as activities increased. Some
difficulty sleeping at night. Both a nurse and physical therapist visited the
house and a plan of walking and exercising three times daily began. (Days 8 thru
14): feeling better each day, sleep is improving , transitioned from walker to
cane on Day 9.
Began driving short distances on Day 14. Eating is back to normal and overall
body strength is improving. (Days 15 thru 17): Feeling great, the surgical area
is tender and I have to change positions frequently. Just got back from a three
quarter mile walk. I must admit it tired me out. I begin outpatient therapy on
April 9th, so I will follow-up at the conclusion of next week. Thanks for your
support
Steve
Friday, July 8. 2011
Larger cups and optimal positioning produced lowest ion levels and wear
In a review of 585 blood serum evaluations following hip resurfacing, only
femoral size and cup inclination were found to have an effect on ion levels,
according a study by orthopedic investigators.
The findings were presented at the 2010 Annual Meeting of the American
Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.
David J. Langton, MRCS, and his colleagues also found that the size of the
coverage angle of the acetabular component contributed significantly to its
tolerance of suboptimal positioning.
"Larger joints, it must be emphasized, tolerated suboptimal cup position," he
said. "This must be taken into account in all analyses."
Inverse relationships
Using routinely obtained blood serum metal ion levels from patients under the
care of the two senior authors of the paper being presented - both highly
experienced hip resurfacing surgeons - metal ion results were analyzed regarding
their relationship to femoral and acetabular component size and orientation,
UCLA activity score, age, time post surgery and postoperative femoral head/neck
ratios.
Langton reported an inverse relationship between metal ion levels and femoral
size. A smaller acetabular coverage arc was associated with higher metal ion
levels.
Another significant inverse correlation was noted by Langton between metal
ion levels and contact patch to rim (CPR) distance. CPR is a measurement that
relates the position of the articular contact patch with the patient in standing
position to the cup rim. According to the abstract, CPR less than 5 mm is
associated with a 50% chance of ion levels greater than 30 mg/L.
Words of warning
Langton warned the audience, "To increase metal ion levels as quickly as
possible, use as small a bearing diameter as possible, use a cup with the
smallest coverage arc, and combine very high anteversion with high inclination."
He concluded, "Cups placed with angles between 40° and 50° inclination and 10°
to 20° anteversion have the lowest ion levels and the lowest rates of volumetric
wear."
Reference:
Langton D, Jameson S, Joyce T, et al. A review of 585 serum metal ion results
post hip resurfacing: cup design and position is critical. Paper 006. Presented
at the 2010 Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.
March 9-13. New Orleans.
Langton has received research or institutional support from DePuy, a Johnson
& Johnson Company, DJ Orthopaedics; he has also received miscellaneous
non-income support (e.g., equipment or services) from DePuy, a Johnson & Johnson
Company.
Friday, July 8. 2011
Mar 7, 2007
I had a check up today at the Royal Orthopaedic in Birmingham after 15.5
years of having had my resurfacing and thought I would post an update. My check
up went very well and it looks like my hip is still going very strong. The x-ray
showed no change since my last check up 2 years ago which I was really pleased
to hear.
For anyone who hasn't read my posts before, my kids were born 2 years and 7
years post op. They are now 13 and 8. They are very fit and well with absolutely
no signs of any ill affects from metal ions that may or may not have passed
across to them during pregnancy.
I am not a gym bunny and don't do any extreme sports, instead I keep fit by
walking (especially walking around shops looking for shoes - I must do a ten
mile hike doing that on a Saturday afternoon!!)
Katie
Lhip McMinn 1991
Mar 24, 2004
I thought I'd share my experience as I am an old surface-hippy, not in age
but in the number of years post op. I had mine done by Mr. McMinn at the ROH in
Birmingham when the procedure was a twinkle in most peoples eyes. I had CDH
which was only diagnosed at 4yrs so I had many ops to try to 'build' a hip
socket but it finally gave up the ghost and I was faced with either a non tried
and tested new op or a THR. I didn't think there was much choice!! I had my left
hip resurfaced in September 1991 when I was 21 - Mr. McMinn was still pioneering
it and I was the youngest person to have it at that time. I had to have bone
grafting at the same time so my post op recovery took longer than normal. I was
in traction for 4 weeks & crutches for a few months but it meant I could walk
down the isle in 1992 with no hint of a limp which made my Mum cry! 2 years
later I had my first baby followed by another one 5 years after that. .
I would encourage anyone who is worried about the longevity of this procedure
not to worry and go for it!
Katie
Lhip McMinn 1991
Friday, July 8. 2011
http://www.mcminncentre.co.uk/mitchell-hill-metal-on-metal-hip-resurfacing.html
Mitchell Hill Celebrates 20 Years with his Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing
Mitchell Hill had a McMinn Cementless Resurfacing in 1991 at the age of just 24.
Following his surgery he was able to get back to a pain free, active lifestyle.
He recently celebrated the 20th year of his MoM Hip Resurfacing. View his
interview below.

|